Mexican sour gherkin is a rather new name for a cute little fruit that native people of Mexico and Central America have enjoyed since pre-Columbian times. Melothria scabra, as botanists know it, is often called sandita, “little watermelon,” in Spanish and “mouse melon” in various languages.* These are better names, I think, because although a Mexican sour gherkin is only about an inch long, it looks like a classic watermelon–oval, smooth-skinned, vine-borne, with dark green lengthwise stripes on a pale green background. The taste, though lacking sweetness, is mildly tart, like a watermelon’s, with the aroma of cucumber. As the fruit matures, the stripes fade and the flesh becomes remarkably sour.
Although the Mexican sour gherkin . . . Wait. Can we scrap that awkward name for one that’s easier to say? Although the sandita is in the family Cucurbitaceae, it’s only a distant relative of the watermelon and the cucumber. Some anglo starting calling the sandita a gherkin because you can use it as a gherkin—that is, as a small cucumber. You can pickle it whole.
The compact sandita vine makes a fine ornamental. You can grow it in a pot, though you’ll want the plant at a level at which you can easily hunt under the foliage for the fruits. The leaves are light green, ivy-like, rough to the touch (hence the species name scabra) but not nearly as rough as cucumber leaves, and much less disease-prone, in my experience so far, than are cucumber and melon leaves.
I’ve just pickled my first sanditas. Because I have only one plant, collecting enough fruit to fill a jar took several days. Fortunately, the fruits kept well in the refrigerator, with no sign of deterioration. When I was ready to fill my jar, I didn’t mar the fruit by cutting away the blossom ends; instead I lightly scraped them away with a fingernail.
As the main flavoring for the sanditas I chose tarragon, which is typically used in pickling cornichons. If you dislike licorice-like flavors, you might substitute herbs such as thyme, savory, and bay, or you might use traditional gherkin flavorings such as mustard and dill. I added honey because I thought it would complement the sanditas’ flavor, though the honey slightly darkened the pickling liquid. You might prefer to use white sugar or no sweetening at all. For very sour pickles—to complement, say, pâté or cocktails—use straight vinegar instead of cutting it with water.
4 allspice berries
8 black peppercorns
¼ teaspoon coriander seeds
1 1/3 cups white wine vinegar
2/3 cup water
1½ teaspoon pickling salt
3 tablespoons honey
1 quart sanditas (Melothria scabra), blossom ends scraped clean
1 large sprig tarragon
In a mortar, lightly crush the allspice, black pepper, and coriander seeds. In a small saucepan, combine the crushed spices with the vinegar, water, salt, and honey. Bring the liquid to a boil, and then let it cool for 5 minutes.
Pack the sanditas into a quart jar along with the tarragon. Pour the hot liquid over them, right to the top of the jar (add a little more vinegar if you don’t have enough liquid to fill the jar to the top). Screw on a lid; if it’s metal, put a piece of plastic wrap in between. Let the jar sit at room temperature for at least three days before tasting the pickles. After that they should keep well at room temperature, but you may prefer to eat them chilled.
After three days of pickling the sanditas make a crisp, mildly tart snack; you may find yourself downing them by the dozen. Over time they’ll get more sour and more suitable as an accompaniment to fatty foods.
With my next batch of pickled sanditas, I plan to stab each fruit with a fork before packing the jar. This way the sanditas will have less tendency to float in the jar, and the pickles will be ready sooner.
*Note that this is a different species from Melothria pendula, which grows wild from the southeastern United States to Argentina and bears some of the same popular names. Though many people use the unripe fruits of Melothria pendula in pickles and salads, others consider the whole plant toxic. When the fruit ripens to nearly black, apparently, it becomes an extremely effective remedy for constipation.
17 thoughts on “Pickling Mexican Sour Gherkins”
How very interesting! I’ve never seen these in western PA!
These look great, would love to try to grow some here in Florida too. Thanks for sharing the recipe and info as always!
Thanks for the recipe. This is my first year growing these and I wasn’t sure when they were ripe. If they ready at an inch long, I’ll get some this year, though not near enough for a quart.
I assumed they were ready at an inch because they didn’t seem to get much bigger. I haven’t found any yet that have changed color or shown other signs of true maturity. I hope I find some ripe ones, though, so I can save the seeds.
Love this post! I bought these once at the Corvallis Farmer’s Market from Matt-Cyn Farms. But never thought of pickling them. Loved the miniature watermelon look. Miss you and Oregon, Linda. Just saw your pickling book recommended on the popular “Food in Jars” website. Look forward to you possibly visiting in Maine when you are back East!
I’d love to try my hand at growing these. Did you start your plant from seeds you purchased, or from the fruit itself?
I started the plants from seeds I bought from Seed Savers Exchange. This year I’ll save seeds, if any of the fruits fully mature.
THANK YOU!!!!! Got these in my CSA and they said they were West Indian Gherkins. These are the ones I actually got. So doing this tonight!
I was recently introduced to these and one of my first thoughts was, those would make a great pickle!
I grew these last season, once the plant finished producing and died I tipped out the potting mix to find a large, white tubers….are these tubers edible?
This exciting news sent me straight to the garden to dig in the spot where my gherkins grew. Alas, no tubers. Maybe they failed to form because of our short growing season, or maybe they rotted in the wet earth. But I can’t find any mention of tubers in the literature about this plant, besides a brief query on Garden Web. If you have the nerve to taste one of the tubers, please let us know how they are.
I’ve tasted just a tiny bit of the raw cucamellon tuber, It was very crunchy like an apple, very juicy like a full sized cucumber, the taste was mild, all i could liken it too was a raw potato but milder and a bit of a slight nutty aftertaste.
Right after eating it i described it as crisp and refreshing, surprisingly pleasant. I probably swallowed a 1 cm cube size piece after chewing it. It didn’t make me feel sick, it wasn’t bitter in the slightest. it kind of left a mild oily feel in my mouth afterwards which was unusual and i didn’t go back for seconds because i don’t know if they are edible! Couldn’t find anything on the web either but i do know choko tubers are edible and they are related.
Cucamelon! That name is new to me. Are you Australian, Peter?
After my last comment about tubers I found and dug some and tried to keep them in the garage over the winter. Apparently they completely liquified. This year I will probably put the pot in which my plants are growing into the greenhouse, add mulch, and see if the tubers survive.
Choko is another name for chayote, right? Since cucamelons and chokos are in different genera, I wouldn’t make assumptions about edibility, but your experiment is promising. If I get plenty of tubers this year, I’ll try biting one.
Do you have a Dill Pickle recipe for these?
Susie, I am amused to see that I left the tarragon out of this recipe, although I both showed tarragon in the photo and mentioned it in the introductory text. I have just added tarragon to the recipe. Now, to make dilled sanditas, simply substitute a couple of dill heads and a frond or two for the tarragon.